A prominent Saudi scholar, Imam of Jeddah Mosque, Asim al-Hakim, has recently made a declaration regarding the earnings from YouTube, stating that they are considered haram, meaning forbidden in Islamic law. The statement came in response to a question posed by a Twitter user named Abdul Maqtadir, who sought clarification on whether earning from YouTube is permissible or not.
Asim al-Hakim’s response was straightforward, simply stating that YouTube earnings are haram. However, he did not elaborate on the reasons behind this ruling in his initial Twitter response. For those seeking more insight into his perspective, a statement made by the scholar on his YouTube channel four years ago sheds light on his views.
In his earlier statement, Asim al-Hakim highlighted that, from an Islamic perspective, earning from YouTube is not inherently forbidden. The permissibility of YouTube earnings depends on the nature of the content that the YouTuber uploads. If the content contains elements that are considered haram in Islam, such as music, women displayed immodestly, indecent conversations, obscenity, or immorality, then the income derived from such content would be deemed haram.
In essence, according to Asim al-Hakim, the source of income becomes impermissible if it originates from promoting content that goes against Islamic principles and values. On the other hand, if the content is deemed permissible and adheres to Islamic guidelines, the earnings generated through YouTube would not be considered haram.
Asim al-Hakim holds a significant position as he leads the Friday prayers at Jeddah Mosque, an esteemed role in the religious community. He has also been featured as a host and guest on various TV programs, allowing him to reach a wide audience. Moreover, his knowledge and wisdom have led him to deliver lectures at several universities in Asia and Europe, further cementing his influence as a respected scholar.
YouTube has become a major platform for content creators and influencers, especially among the younger generation. The potential to earn a substantial income through advertising revenue and brand partnerships has attracted many individuals to pursue careers as YouTubers. However, Asim al-Hakim’s ruling serves as a reminder that with this lucrative occupation comes a responsibility to ensure that the content produced aligns with Islamic ethics.
While Asim al-Hakim’s stance may be influential within the Muslim community, it’s important to recognize that different scholars and Islamic authorities may have varying interpretations on this matter. As with any religious ruling, individual believers are encouraged to seek guidance from knowledgeable scholars and to exercise personal discernment in determining the permissibility of their actions.
In conclusion, Imam Asim al-Hakim’s declaration regarding YouTube earnings being considered haram has sparked discussions and reflections among Muslims who engage with the platform. As the world continues to evolve, religious scholars are continually addressing contemporary issues, guiding their followers through the intricacies of applying religious principles in the modern age.